Assessment of Medical Students' Shared Decision-Making in Standardized Patient Encounters.

15:53 EDT 23rd August 2014 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "Assessment of Medical Students' Shared Decision-Making in Standardized Patient Encounters."


BACKGROUND:
Shared decision-making, in which physicians and patients openly explore beliefs, exchange information, and reach explicit closure, may represent optimal physician-patient communication. There are currently no universally accepted methods to assess medical students' competence in shared decision-making.
OBJECTIVE:
To characterize medical students' shared decision-making with standardized patients (SPs) and determine if students' use of shared decision-making correlates with SP ratings of their communication.
DESIGN:
Retrospective study of medical students' performance with four SPs.
PARTICIPANTS:
Sixty fourth-year medical students.
MEASUREMENTS:
Objective blinded coding of shared decision-making quantified as decision moments (exploration/articulation of perspective, information sharing, explicit closure for a particular decision); SP scoring of communication skills using a validated checklist.
RESULTS:
Of 779 decision moments generated in 240 encounters, 312 (40%) met criteria for shared decision-making. All students engaged in shared decision-making in at least two of the four cases, although in two cases 5% and 12% of students engaged in no shared decision-making. The most commonly discussed decision moment topics were medications (n = 98, 31%), follow-up visits (71, 23%), and diagnostic testing (44, 14%). Correlations between the number of decision moments in a case and students' communication scores were low (rho = 0.07 to 0.37).
CONCLUSIONS:
Although all students engaged in some shared decision-making, particularly regarding medical interventions, there was no correlation between shared decision-making and overall communication competence rated by the SPs. These findings suggest that SP ratings of students' communication skill cannot be used to infer students' use of shared decision-making. Tools to determine students' skill in shared decision-making are needed.

Affiliation

Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, 505 Parnassus Ave, M1078, Box 0120, San Francisco, CA, 94143-0120, USA, karen.hauer@ucsf.edu.

Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: Journal of general internal medicine
ISSN: 1525-1497
Pages:

Links

PubMed Articles [29587 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Shared decision making: what do clinicians need to know and why should they bother?

Shared decision making enables a clinician and patient to participate jointly in making a health decision, having discussed the options and their benefits and harms, and having considered the patient'...

Measuring critical deficits in shared decision making before elective surgery.

Identifying patient factors correlated with specific needs in preoperative decision making is of clinical and ethical importance. We examined patterns and predictors of deficiencies in informed surgic...

Identifying design considerations for a shared decision aid for use at the point of outpatient clinical care: An ethnographic study at an inner city clinic.

Computerized decision aids could facilitate shared decision-making at the point of outpatient clinical care. The objective of this study was to investigate whether a computerized shared decision aid w...

Impact of DECISION + 2 on patient and physician assessment of shared decision making implementation in the context of antibiotics use for acute respiratory infections.

DECISION + 2, a training program for physicians, is designed to implement shared decision making (SDM) in the context of antibiotics use for acute respiratory tract infections (ARTIs). We evaluated th...

Patient preferences for testing for pulmonary embolism in the ED using a shared decision-making model.

Shared decision making (SDM) is a process whereby patients and clinicians work together to make informed medical decisions that incorporate patient values. Recent data suggest that, for patients with...

Clinical Trials [4279 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

Shared Decision-Making for Elderly Depressed Primary Care Patients

Shared decision-making (SDM), in contrast to traditional medical decision-making, involves a collaborative process where patients discuss personal values and preferences and clinicians pro...

Shared Decision Making: Prostate Cancer Screening

Interventions to Improve Shared Decision-Making: Prostate Cancer Screening is a prospective study of educational interventions to improve the interaction of physicians and their patients a...

Does Shared Decision-Making Improve Asthma Outcomes?

To improve asthma outcomes by developing and evaluating strategies for enhancing the clinic-patient partnership. To develop a model of shared decision-making for asthma treatment, and to...

Development of a Web-Based Interactive Patient Decision Aid for the Treatment of Acute Low Back Pain and Depression

Shared decision making (SDM) has been advocated as an appropriate approach for physician patient communication. Positive effects of SDM are e.g higher patient satisfaction, greater treatme...

Shared Decision-Making for Colorectal Cancer Screening

The overall objective of this study is to conduct a three-arm randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of an interactive, web-based decision aid on shared decision-making and pat...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

Mathematical or statistical procedures used as aids in making a decision. They are frequently used in medical decision-making.

Information systems, usually computer-assisted, that enable providers to initiate medical procedures, prescribe medications, etc. These systems support medical decision-making and error-reduction during patient care.

Patient involvement in the decision-making process in matters pertaining to health.

Computer-based information systems used to integrate clinical and patient information and provide support for decision-making in patient care.

Use of an interactive computer system designed to assist the physician or other health professional in choosing between certain relationships or variables for the purpose of making a diagnostic or therapeutic decision.

Search BioPortfolio: