A cost-utility analysis of medium vs. high-fidelity human patient simulation manikins in nursing education.

06:00 EDT 16th September 2011 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "A cost-utility analysis of medium vs. high-fidelity human patient simulation manikins in nursing education."

Aims and objectives.  This study presents a cost-utility analysis that compared medium- vs. high-fidelity human patient simulation manikins in nursing education. The analysis sought to determine whether the extra costs associated with high-fidelity manikins can justify the differences, if any, in the outcomes of clinical reasoning, knowledge acquisition and student satisfaction. Background.  Investment in simulated learning environments has increased at an unprecedented pace. One of the driving forces is the potential for simulation experiences to improve students' learning and engagement. A cost-effectiveness analysis is needed to inform decisions related to investment in and use of simulation equipment. Method.  Costs associated with the use of medium- and high-fidelity manikins were calculated to determine the total cost for each. A cost-utility analysis using multiattribute utility function was then conducted to combine costs and three outcomes of clinical reasoning, knowledge acquisition and student satisfaction from a quasi-experimental study to arrive at an overall cost utility. Results.  The cost analysis indicated that to obtain equivalent clinical reasoning, knowledge acquisition and student satisfaction scores, it required $AU1·21 (US$ 1·14; €0·85) using medium-fidelity as compared with $AU6·28 (US$6·17; €4·40) for high-fidelity human patient simulation manikins per student. Conclusion.  Based on the results of the cost-utility analysis, medium-fidelity manikins are more cost effective requiring one-fifth of the cost of high-fidelity manikins to obtain the same effect on clinical reasoning, knowledge acquisition and student satisfaction. Relevance to clinical practice.  It is important that decision-makers have an economic analysis that considers both the costs and outcomes of simulation to identify the approach that has the lowest cost for any particular outcome measure or the best outcomes for a particular cost.


Authors: Samuel Lapkin, BN, RN, PhD Candidate, Research Assistant and Academic, School of Nursing and Midwifery, The University of Newcastle; Tracy Levett-Jones, BN, PhD, RN, MEd & Work, DipAppSc(Nursing), Deputy Head of School (Teaching and Learning), Sc

Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: Journal of clinical nursing
ISSN: 1365-2702


DeepDyve research library

PubMed Articles [56268 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Cost Utility Analysis of Lumbar Interlaminar Epidural Injections in the Treatment of Lumbar Disc Herniation, Central Spinal Stenosis, and Axial or Discogenic Low Back Pain.

Cost utility or cost effective analysis continues to take center stage in the United States for defining and measuring the value of treatments in interventional pain management. Appropriate cost utili...

Cost-Utility Analysis of Bariatric Surgery in Italy: Results of Decision-Analytic Modelling.

To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of bariatric surgery in Italy from a third-party payer perspective over a medium-term (10 years) and a long-term (lifetime) horizon.

The case for investing in the male condom.

When used correctly and consistently, the male condom offers triple protection from unintended pregnancy and the transmission of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and human immunodeficiency virus...

A cost utility analysis of high molecular weight hyaluronic acid for knee osteoarthritis in everyday clinical care in patients in the working age. An economic evaluation of a randomized clinical trial.

Objectives Knee osteoarthritis (OA) is associated with high medical costs and especially with high productivity costs, in particular in patients in their working years. High molecular weight (HMW) hya...

Utilization Management of High-Cost Imaging in an Outpatient Setting in a Large Stable Patient and Provider Cohort over 7 Years.

Purpose To quantify the effect of a comprehensive, long-term, provider-led utilization management (UM) program on high-cost imaging (computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, nuclear imaging, a...

Clinical Trials [12059 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

Cost Utility Analysis of Erythropoietin for Anemia Treatment in Hemodialysis Patients

To study the cost utility analysis of Erythropoietin (EPO) for maintaining the different hemoglobin (Hb) target levels in anemic hemodialysis patient in routine clinical practice.

High-fidelity Simulation in Health Care Education

The purpose of this study is to determine whether the use of high-fidelity simulation in health care education is an effective training and evaluation model.

High Fidelity Simulation vs Standard Teaching Training of Cardiac Resuscitation

High fidelity Simulation has spread from anesthesiology to other disciplines such as internal medicine, pediatrics, and emergency medicine . Over the past decade, the use of simulation in ...

Project FACTS (Fidelity Accuracy: Comparing Three Strategies)

The objective is to compare the accuracy, costs, and cost-effectiveness of three fidelity measurement methods to assess fidelity to cognitive-behavioral therapy for youth. The investigator...

Low-fidelity Simulation to Teach Anesthetists' Non-technical Skills in Rwanda

The goal of this study is to examine whether low‐fidelity instructor‐driven simulation can provide effective teaching of anesthetists' non‐technical skills in a developing world cont...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

A method of comparing the cost of a program with its expected benefits in dollars (or other currency). The benefit-to-cost ratio is a measure of total return expected per unit of money spent. This analysis generally excludes consideration of factors that are not measured ultimately in economic terms. Cost effectiveness compares alternative ways to achieve a specific set of results.

The personal cost of acute or chronic disease. The cost to the patient may be an economic, social, or psychological cost or personal loss to self, family, or immediate community. The cost of illness may be reflected in absenteeism, productivity, response to treatment, peace of mind, QUALITY OF LIFE, etc. It differs from HEALTH CARE COSTS, meaning the societal cost of providing services related to the delivery of health care, rather than personal impact on individuals.

Absolute, comparative, or differential costs pertaining to services, institutions, resources, etc., or the analysis and study of these costs.

A controlled learning environment that closely represents reality.

The assignment, to each of several particular cost-centers, of an equitable proportion of the costs of activities that serve all of them. Cost-center usually refers to institutional departments or services.

Quick Search

DeepDyve research library