Sedation Versus No Sedation in a Spontaneous Breathing Trial
Summary
An important part of how we decide when a patient is ready to have their breathing tube removed is to have a person breathe without any machine breaths while the breathing tube is still in place. We call this a spontaneous breathing trial.
Commonly, while patients have the breathing tube, they are given medications to keep them sedated and comfortable so breathing does not bother them. These medicines are often stopped before the spontaneous breathing trial so they can be more awake for the test.
There are signs the doctors look for during the spontaneous breathing trial that suggest the patient might not be ready for the breathing trial to come out. Signs like fast breathing, small breaths, a fast heart rate, or looking more anxious than usual may mean that the patient is not ready to come off the ventilator. However, if someone has been given sedation medicines the entire time they have had a breathing tube and are then woken up, they may naturally get very anxious. They may show the same signs as someone who is failing their breathing test, but in their case these signs are only because they are anxious.Doctors may mistake these signs as failing the breathing test and may not pull the breathing tube out even though the patient is really ready for it to come out.
We wish to try and find out if patients do better during their spontaneous breathing trials if they are continued on some sedative medicines to treat anxiety or if they do better if the medicines are stopped before the test.
Description
All intubated patients cared for by the Medical Intensive Care Unit (MICU)team during the study period will be evaluated. After 24 hours of mechanical ventilation, patients not meeting any exclusionary criteria will be considered for entrance into our trial. We will attempt to obtain consent as soon as the 24 hour period is fulfilled, even if the patient is not ready for extubation at that point. This is to maximize the success rate for obtaining consent without delaying the SBT when the patient is clinically ready. Given the nature of this protocol, we expect that the informed consent will primarily be obtained from the patient's family member or POA. For all patients who regain competency, they will be re-consented for permission to use their data that has been collected.
Once patients are consented, they will be followed daily by the study investigators. When the order is written by the MICU team for the patient to undergo a SBT, the patient's level of consciousness will be evaluated by the nursing staff using the RASS. If the patient's score is <(-2), they will notify the study investigators. The patient will then be randomized by sealed envelope to one of two study groups. Group 1 will immediately undergo their SBT while still sedated. Group 2 will have their sedation held. Once their RASS score is 0 or higher and they can follow simple commands (holding up two fingers to command), they will be initiated on their SBT.
The standard duration of an SBT by protocol is 2 hours. The duration of SBT may be shorter at the discretion of the ICU attending physician. Additionally, the standard ventilators settings for an SBT is 10 cm of Pressure Support and 5 cm of PEEP (positive and expiratory pressure). This may vary some by the attending's preference though we encourage the use of the standard setting during the study unless there is a clear need to deviate from the protocol. This is to limit the confounding impact that differing levels of Pressure Support may have on the parameters tracked. Patients who are felt to be failing the SBt will be placed back on fill ventilator support at any point directed by the MICU team. Given the lack of objective criteria to define failure of SBT, there are no clear criteria defined and the decision that a patient is failing their SBT will be determined by the attending physician.
Nursing staff will be provided with a documentation form (Data sheet 1) and asked to annotate heart rate, blood pressure, respiratory rate, tidal volume, oxygen saturation, and RASS score at 0, 15, 30, 60 minutes and at the conclusion of the SBT.They will be inserviced on the protocol prior to the start of the study. The study investigators will collect demographic information and record it on Data sheet 2. In addition to the primary endpoint(changes in cardiopulmonary parameters and RASS collected by the nursing staff), secondary endpoints will include outcome of first SBT(pass or fail), time from randomization to extubation, outcome of the first extubation (Data sheet 1). As stated earlier, there are no clearly defined cut-off values for any of the monitored variables that define failure of an SBT.
Study Design
Allocation: Randomized, Endpoint Classification: Efficacy Study, Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment, Masking: Open Label, Primary Purpose: Supportive Care
Conditions
Respiratory Insufficiency
Intervention
Sedation during SBT, No sedation
Location
Memorial Medical Center
Johnstown
Pennsylvania
United States
15905
Status
Terminated
Source
Memorial Medical Center
Results (where available)
Links
- Source: http://clinicaltrials.gov/show/NCT00366353
- Information obtained from ClinicalTrials.gov on July 15, 2010
Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions
Promethazine
A phenothiazine derivative with histamine H1-blocking, antimuscarinic, and sedative properties. It is used as an antiallergic, in pruritus, for motion sickness and sedation, and also in animals.
Chlorpheniramine
A histamine H1 antagonist used in allergic reactions, hay fever, rhinitis, urticaria, and asthma. It has also been used in veterinary applications. One of the most widely used of the classical antihistaminics, it generally causes less drowsiness and sedation than PROMETHAZINE.
Deep Sedation
Drug-induced depression of consciousness during which patients cannot be easily aroused but respond purposely following repeated painful stimulation. The ability to independently maintain ventilatory function may be impaired. (From: American Society of Anesthesiologists Practice Guidelines)
Conscious Sedation
A drug-induced depression of consciousness during which patients respond purposefully to verbal commands, either alone or accompanied by light tactile stimulation. No interventions are required to maintain a patent airway. (From: American Society of Anesthesiologists Practice Guidelines)
Pentobarbital
A short-acting barbiturate that is effective as a sedative and hypnotic (but not as an anti-anxiety) agent and is usually given orally. It is prescribed more frequently for sleep induction than for sedation but, like similar agents, may lose its effectiveness by the second week of continued administration. (From AMA Drug Evaluations Annual, 1994, p236)
Clinical Trials
Ketamine Sedation in Mechanically Ventilated Patients
- Adequate sedation is of paramount importance to avoid stress and pain in mechanically ventilated patients. It is usually achieved by infusing sedatives (benzodiazepine) and an...
Effects of Remifentanil on Respiratory Function in Mechanically Ventilated Patients
Sedation is widely used in mechanically ventilated patients. Propofol, benzodiazepines and opioids are the most used drugs. The study hypothesis is that sedation with remifentanil (an opio...
Sedation and Psychopharmacology in Critical Care
Certain methods of sedation increase the duration of respiratory failure. Two strategies, a nursing- implemented sedation algorithm and daily interruption of sedatives, decrease length of...
Combined Ketamine/Propofol for Emergency Department Procedural Sedation
Introduction Numerous drugs and combinations of drugs are used for procedural sedation and analgesia (PSA) in Emergency Departments, including propofol, ketamine, benzodiazepines, narcoti...
Combining Objective and Subjective Sedation Assessment Tools
The purpose of this study is to determine if the use of a device called the BIS monitor in addition to the Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale will give better assessment of a subject's leve...
PubMed Articles
While the control of pain and anxiety is fundamental to the practice of dentistry, the use of conscious sedation in dentistry is very variable among dentists. The need for conscious sedation could be...
While the control of pain and anxiety is fundamental to the practice of dentistry, the use of conscious sedation in dentistry is very variable among dentists. The need for conscious sedation could be...
The changing faces of endoscopic sedation.
The practice of sedation for digestive endoscopy continues to evolve throughout the world. In many countries, there is a trend for increased utilization of sedation during routine endoscopic procedure...
Objective The indications for endoscopic treatment in early stage cancer of the digestive tract are expanding with the emergence and technical development of endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD). ES...
Objective-To determine the effects of IM administration of acepromazine, hydromorphone, or the acepromazine-hydromorphone combination on degree of sedation in clinically normal dogs and to compare 2 s...
