Generating the perception of choice: the remarkable malleability of option-listing.

08:00 EDT 3rd August 2018 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "Generating the perception of choice: the remarkable malleability of option-listing."

The normative view that patients should be offered more choice both within and beyond the UK's National Health Service (NHS) has been increasingly endorsed. However, there is very little research on whether - and how - this is enacted in practice. Based on 223 recordings of neurology outpatient consultations and participants' subsequent self-reports, this article shows that 'option-listing' is a key practice for generating the perception of choice. The evidence is two-fold: first, we show that neurologists and patients overwhelmingly reported that choice was offered in those consultations where option-listing was used; second, we demonstrate how option-listing can be seen, in the interaction itself, to create a moment of choice for the patient. Surprisingly, however, we found that even when the patient resisted making the choice or the neurologist adapted the practice of option-listing in ways that sought acceptance of the neurologist's own recommendation, participants still agreed that a choice had been offered. There was only one exception: despite the use of option-listing, the patient reported having no choice, whereas the neurologist reported having offered a choice. We explore this deviant case in order to shed light on the limits of option-listing as a mechanism for generating the perception of choice.


Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: Sociology of health & illness
ISSN: 1467-9566


DeepDyve research library

PubMed Articles [6566 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Multiple Listing in Lung Transplant Candidates: A Cohort Study.

Lung transplant candidates can be waitlisted at more than one transplant center, a practice known as multiple listing. The factors associated with multiple listing and whether multiple listing modifie...

A systematic review and novel classification of listing tools to improve medication in older people.

Suboptimal drugs therapy is a threat to older people, and listing tools providing guidance are developed to address this problem.

NPR1 paralogs of Arabidopsis and their role in salicylic acid perception.

Salicylic acid (SA) is responsible for certain plant defence responses and NON EXPRESSER OF PATHOGENESIS RELATED 1 (NPR1) is the master regulator of SA perception. In Arabidopsis thaliana there are fi...

Corticostriatal Circuits Encode the Subjective Value of Perceived Control.

The ability to perceive and exercise control over an outcome is both desirable and beneficial to our well-being. It has been shown that animals and humans alike exhibit behavioral bias towards seeking...

Understanding the consumer's perception of traditional frankfurters and frankfurters with healthy attributes through sorting task and hard laddering techniques.

This study evaluated the consumer's perception towards traditional frankfurters and frankfurters with healthy attributes through sorting task and hard laddering techniques. Images with descriptions of...

Clinical Trials [2955 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]


Obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (SAOS), very commonly associated with obesity, induces major disturbances in sleep architecture. The hypotheses in this work are twofold: on the one hand, ...

Evaluation of a Decision Aid for Adult Cystic Fibrosis Patients Considering Bilateral Lung Transplantation

In 2006, the International Patient Decision Aids Collaboration (IPDAS) reached agreement on criteria for evaluation. Accordingly, the primary outcome is 'decision quality' 3 weeks after u...

Subacute and Chronic, Non-specific Back and Neck Pain: Cognitive-behavioral Rehabilitation vs. Traditional Primary Care

BACKGROUND Non-specific back and neck pain (BNP) dominates sick-listing. A program of cognitive-behavioral rehabilitation for subacute and chronic BNP was compared, with 18-month fo...

Adherence to Osteoporosis Treatment and Physicians' Perception Regarding Osteoporosis Medication

This is a study aiming to investigate a possible correlation between the parameters affecting the physicians' therapeutic choice with the patients' overall adherence to osteoporosis treatm...

What Matters Most: Choosing the Right Breast Cancer Surgery for You

What Matters Most is a study that aims to determine how best to help women of lower socioeconomic status make high-quality decisions about early stage breast cancer treatments. What Matter...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

Perception of three-dimensionality.

Laws requiring patients under managed care programs to receive services from the physician or other provider of their choice. Any willing provider laws take many different forms, but they typically prohibit managed-care organizations from having a closed panel of physicians, hospitals, or other providers.

A clinical syndrome characterized by repeated spontaneous hemorrhages and a remarkable increase in the number of circulating platelets.

The process by which the nature and meaning of gustatory stimuli are recognized and interpreted by the brain. The four basic classes of taste perception are salty, sweet, bitter, and sour.

Neurological condition characterized by disturbances in VISUAL PERCEPTION, most often of BODY SCHEMA, TIME PERCEPTION and HALLUCINATIONS. It is associated with MIGRAINE, infections (e.g., INFECTIOUS MONONUCLEOSIS), FEVER, EPILEPSY, and other neurological and psychiatric disorders.

Quick Search


DeepDyve research library

Relevant Topic

Neurology - Central Nervous System (CNS)
Alzheimer's Disease Anesthesia Anxiety Disorders Autism Bipolar Disorders Dementia Epilepsy Multiple Sclerosis (MS) Neurology Pain Parkinson's Disease Sleep Disorders Neurology is the branch of me...

Searches Linking to this Article