Addressing the ethical grey zone in surgery: a framework for identification and safe introduction of novel surgical techniques and procedures.

08:00 EDT 11th April 2019 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "Addressing the ethical grey zone in surgery: a framework for identification and safe introduction of novel surgical techniques and procedures."

While the introduction of new surgical techniques can radically improve patient care, they may equally expose patients to unforeseen harms associated with untested procedures. The enthusiastic uptake of laparoscopic cholecystectomy in the early 1990s saw a dramatic increase in the rate of common bile duct injuries, and was described by Alfred Cuschieri as 'the biggest unaudited free-for-all in the history of surgery' due to 'a lack of effective centralised control'. Whether a new surgical intervention is considered an acceptable 'minor' variation of an established procedure, or is sufficiently 'novel' to constitute experimentation on human subjects is often unclear. Furthermore, once a new technique is identified as experimental, there is no agreed protocol for safety evaluation in a first-in-human setting. In phase I (first-in-human) pharmacological trials only small, single arm cohorts of highly selected patients are enrolled in order to establish the safety profile of a new drug. This exposes only a small number of patients to the unknown or unforeseen risks that may be associated with a new agent, in a highly regulated and scientifically rigorous manner. There is no equivalent study design for the introduction of new and experimental surgical procedures. This article proposes a practical stepwise approach to the safe introduction of new surgical procedures that surgeons and surgical departments can adopt. It includes criteria for new surgical techniques which require formal prospective ethical evaluation, and a novel study design for conducting a safety evaluation at the 'first in human' stage.


Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: ANZ journal of surgery
ISSN: 1445-2197


DeepDyve research library

PubMed Articles [21070 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Does One Health require a novel ethical framework?

Emerging infectious diseases (EIDs) remain a significant and dynamic threat to the health of individuals and the well-being of communities across the globe. Over the last decade, in response to these ...

Surgical "Safe Zone": Rapid Anatomical Identification of the Lesser Occipital Nerve.

 Surgical intervention has established a vital role in the management of chronic headaches. The lesser occipital nerve (LON) is a common target in patients suffering from occipital neuralgia and is ...

Surgical, Clinical, and Functional Outcomes in Patients with Rectosigmoid Endometriosis in the Grey Zone: 13-Year Long-term Follow-up.

To date, there is no consensus regarding the choice between radical (segmental resection) or conservative (shaving, discoid excision) surgical management for rectosigmoid endometriosis (RSE), in parti...

Progress of the laryngeal framework surgery.

Isshiki systematically developed thyroplasty in the 1970 s. Based on Isshiki's classification of thyroplasty, laryngeal framework surgery was classified by the Phonosurgery Committee of the European L...

Responsibility and Sustainability in Brain Science, Technology, and Neuroethics in China-a Culture-Oriented Perspective.

The China Brain Project is in development. Integrating an ethical framework to identify and assess ethical challenges and plan for solutions is a priority. Here Wang et al. discuss ethical questions ...

Clinical Trials [11132 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

Augmented Pulse Pressure Variation to Predict Fluid Responsiveness in Open Laparotomy

Pulse pressure variation (PPV) is a well-known and widely used dynamic preload indicator based on heart-lung interaction to predict fluid responsiveness. Generally, patients are considered...

Comparison Between Injection Molded PEEK Framework and Cobalt Chromium Framework in Removable Partial Denture Regarding Retention

This study is aiming to evaluate the retentive forces in PEEK framework RPD compared to Cobalt-Chrome framework RPD during attachment/detachment cycles in mandibular kennedy class I edentu...

Safety and Efficacy of CD10367 in Psoriasis Vulgaris

This is an exploratory, single-centre, investigator blinded, randomized, controlled, intra-individual study, involving subjects with psoriasis vulgaris. The objective is to evaluate, in a...

Grey Matter Damage at the Earliest Phase of Multiple Sclerosis : a Longitudinal 7T MRI Study

The present study is an opportunity to assess grey matter damage at the earliest phase of Multiple Sclerosis (MS) allowing to a better understanding of its origins and its impact and disea...

Ethical Dilemmas in Anaesthesiology in the Netherlands; a Qualitative Interview Study.

This study will describe which ethical dilemmas are experienced by anesthesiologist in the Dutch Healthcare system and what the current solving strategies are for these issues. Semi- struc...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

The use of systematic methods of ethical examination, such as CASUISTRY or ETHICAL THEORY, in reasoning about moral problems.

Cortical malformations characterized by grey matter-lined cleft or cyst that extends from the EPENDYMA often to the PIA MATER outer surface. The grey matter that lines the cleft is often POLYMICROGYRIA. It is associated with developmental delay, motor disturbance and seizures.

The wide middle zone of the adrenal cortex. This zone produces a series of enzymes that convert PREGNENOLONE to cortisol (HYDROCORTISONE) via 17-ALPHA-HYDROXYPROGESTERONE.

The inner zone of the adrenal cortex. This zone produces the enzymes that convert PREGNENOLONE, a 21-carbon steroid, to 19-carbon steroids (DEHYDROEPIANDROSTERONE; and ANDROSTENEDIONE) via 17-ALPHA-HYDROXYPREGNENOLONE.

A phenothiazine that has been used as a hemostatic, a biological stain, and a dye for wool and silk. Tolonium chloride has also been used as a diagnostic aid for oral and gastric neoplasms and in the identification of the parathyroid gland in thyroid surgery.

Quick Search


DeepDyve research library

Relevant Topics

Surgical treatments
Surgery is a technology consisting of a physical intervention on tissues. All forms of surgery are considered invasive procedures; so-called "noninvasive surgery" usually refers to an excision that does not penetrate the structure being exci...

Clincial Trials
In a clinical trial or interventional study, participants receive specific interventions according to the research plan or protocol created by the investigators. These interventions may be medical products, such as drugs or devices; procedures; or change...

Searches Linking to this Article