Nazis, Teleology, and the Freedom of Conscience: In Response to Gamble and Pruski's 'Medical Acts and Conscientious Objection: What Can a Physician be Compelled to Do?'

07:00 EST 1st December 2019 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "Nazis, Teleology, and the Freedom of Conscience: In Response to Gamble and Pruski's 'Medical Acts and Conscientious Objection: What Can a Physician be Compelled to Do?'"

Medical practitioners of all specialisms (e.g. RN, MD) are identified by their professional titles. Their function is determined by their regulators, and subject to voluntary employment contracts. Whilst they are expected to act in their patients' best interests, there are situations in which a physician - having human rights - can object to certain acts. This right of objetction arises from the recognition of the practitioner's own conscience rather than the end or purpose of the procedure being performed. Gamble and Pruski explore an act-centred morality, and therefore define acts as medical (and subject to compulsion) and non-medical (therefore voluntary). This analysis has merit when applied to health-systems as a whole, but fails to take into account the humanity of physicians and the specific interactions with patients in different contexts. As such, it serves as a way of compelling physicians to act against their conscience rather than protecting them.


Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: The New bioethics : a multidisciplinary journal of biotechnology and the body
ISSN: 2050-2885
Pages: 359-373


DeepDyve research library

PubMed Articles [15649 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Nurses' Strategies for Conscience-based Care Delivery: A Qualitative Study.

Conscience is the core of ethical values. It helps nurses protect patients' rights and provide quality dignified care. Therefore, assessing nurses' strategies for conscience-based care may help facili...

Revisiting darwinian teleology: A case for inclusive fitness as design explanation.

This paper elaborates a general framework to make sense of teleological explanations in Darwinian evolutionary biology. It relies on an attempt to tie natural selection to a sense of optimization. Fir...

Gamble evaluation and evoked reference sets: Why adding a small loss to a gamble increases its attractiveness.

When presented with a gamble involving a chance of winning $9, participants rate it as only moderately attractive. However, when other participants are presented with a gamble that adds a chance of lo...

Cue-Reactive Imagery Mediates the Relationships of Reward Responsiveness with Both Cue-Reactive Urge to Gamble and Positive Affect in Poker-Machine Gamblers.

Previous research has demonstrated that gambling cues (e.g., flashing lights on poker-machines) can trigger an urge to gamble in poker-machine gamblers. However, the psychological mechanisms that prom...

Conscience reconsidered: The moral work of navigating participation in abortion care on labor and delivery.

How do caregivers make decisions about participating in morally contested care, such as abortion? Debates about conscience in the delivery of health care generally assume that participation decisions ...

Clinical Trials [5774 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

FreeDom: Innovative Strategy for the Management of COPD Exacerbations

The main objective of the study is to assess the "FreeDom" innovative strategy (FreeO2 at Domicile) to reduce hospitalization duration in patients with COPD exacerbation. This strategy ass...

SynCardia Freedom Driver System Study

The purposes of this study are to confirm that the Freedom Driver System is a suitable pneumatic driver for clinically stable TAH-t subjects, and that patients and lay caregivers can be t...

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) for Nightmares in Operation Enduring Freedom/Operation Iraqi Freedom (OEF/OIF) Veterans

The purpose of this study is to compare the effectiveness of two talk therapies for OEF/OIF veterans at the Philadelphia and the West Haven VA Medical Centers. Participants will randomly ...

MDR-G7 Freedom Constrained Liners

The objective of this consecutive series PMCF study is to collect data confirming safety, performance and clinical benefits of the G7 Freedom Constrained Liners when used for primary and r...

Effectiveness of Freedom Bed Compared to Manual Turning in Prevention of Pressure Injuries in Persons With Limited Mobility Due to Traumatic Brain Injury and/or Spinal Cord Injury.

Observational comparison on Incidence of Pressure Injury between the Freedom Bed Automated Continuous lateral Rotation Therapy System and Manual Caregiver Re-positioning every 2 hours on a...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

The freedom of patients to review their own medical, genetic, or other health-related records.

Educational programs for medical graduates entering a specialty. They include formal specialty training as well as academic work in the clinical and basic medical sciences, and may lead to board certification or an advanced medical degree.

The component of the personality associated with ethics, standards, and self-criticism - the "conscience". It is derived mainly from identification with parents and parent substitutes.

Freedom from activity.

Medical complexes consisting of medical school, hospitals, clinics, libraries, administrative facilities, etc.

Quick Search

DeepDyve research library

Searches Linking to this Article