Should immediate breast reconstruction be performed in the setting of radiotherapy? An ethical analysis.

07:00 EST 8th November 2019 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "Should immediate breast reconstruction be performed in the setting of radiotherapy? An ethical analysis."

Immediate breast reconstruction (IBR) combined with post-mastectomy radiotherapy (PMRT) is associated with an increased risk for complications. Here, we analyse whether IBR combined with PMRT is ethically acceptable. We employ normative analysis following reflective equilibrium and the principles of Beauchamp and Childress: non-maleficence, beneficence, autonomy, and justice. From the perspective of beneficence and non-maleficence, we can choose either IBR or PMRT according to documented risks and complications, delayed autologous breast reconstruction with corresponding benefits but less risk for complications, or even no reconstruction, which for some women, might be equally beneficial. In such a situation, given the level of severity associated with lacking a breast after mastectomy, IBR violates the principles of beneficence and non-maleficence. To deny an IBR in the context of PMRT does not violate the principle of autonomy as it is normally interpreted in the healthcare system, not even when patient-centred care is taken into consideration. Moreover, there is a risk that the decision of the patient will be affected by heuristics, optimism bias, and surgeon bias. IBR in the context of PMRT could be in conflict with the principle of justice, as it could lead to displacement of care for other patient groups. Furthermore, an acceptable level of cost effectiveness should be low, given that living without a breast is a condition of moderate severity. In conclusion, given the current knowledgebase and established ethical norms within the healthcare system, we find strong ethical reasons not to offer IBR when PMRT is expected.


Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: Journal of plastic surgery and hand surgery
ISSN: 2000-6764
Pages: 1-6


DeepDyve research library

PubMed Articles [12897 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Radiotherapy After Skin-Sparing Mastectomy and Implant-Based Breast Reconstruction.

We evaluated the cosmetic results of radiotherapy (RT) after implant-based reconstruction (IBR).

Postmastectomy radiation therapy using VMAT technique for breast cancer patients with expander reconstruction.

Postmastectomy radiotherapy (PMRT) following immediate breast reconstruction is increasingly adopted in the management of breast cancer patients. We retrospectively evaluate the complication rates of ...

International multidisciplinary expert panel consensus on breast reconstruction and radiotherapy.

Conflicting evidence challenges clinical decision-making when breast reconstruction is considered in the context of radiotherapy. Current literature was evaluated and key statements on topical issues ...

ESTRO consensus guideline for target volume delineation in the setting of postmastectomy radiation therapy after implant-based immediate reconstruction for early stage breast cancer.

Immediate breast reconstruction (IBR) rates after mastectomy are increasing. Postmastectomy radiation therapy (PMRT) contouring guidelines for target volumes in the setting of IBR are lacking. Therefo...

Serratus anterior muscle flap as a salvage procedure in exposed implant-based breast reconstruction.

Implant-based breast reconstruction (IBR) is the most common approach to reconstruct mastectomy deffects. Infection following breast reconstruction can be devastating and lead to loss of the reconstru...

Clinical Trials [10397 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

Delayed-Immediate Breast Reconstruction

The goal of this clinical research study is to evaluate a new two-stage approach (delayed-immediate reconstruction) to breast reconstruction in women who may require post-mastectomy radiat...

Delayed-immediate Versus Delayed Breast Reconstruction in Breast Cancer Patients With Mastectomy and Radiation Therapy

In breast cancer patients treated by mastectomy and adjuvant post-mastectomy radiation therapy (PMRT) reconstruction is often delayed until 6 - 12 month after completion of chemotherapy an...

Pilot Study Assessing Breast Temperature in Breast Cancer Patients

Our investigators plan to measure the skin on the breast six months after breast reconstruction. The non-reconstructed breast will be used as the control for subject with unilateral recons...

Effect of Radiation and Its Timing on Breast Reconstruction in Chinese Patients

The purpose of the study is to investigate the impacts of radiation and the timing of radiation on autologous and prosthetic-based breast reconstruction in Chinese post-mastectomy breast c...

Direct to Implant Breast Reconstruction Based Pre- or Retropectoral

The purpose of this study is to examine different outcomes of breast reconstruction in women who are treated for breast cancer with skin sparing mastectomy and subsequently a primary impla...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

Endovascular reconstruction of an artery, which may include the removal of atheromatous plaque and/or the endothelial lining as well as simple dilatation. These are procedures performed by catheterization. When reconstruction of an artery is performed surgically, it is called ENDARTERECTOMY.

Surgical excision, performed under general anesthesia, of the atheromatous tunica intima of an artery. When reconstruction of an artery is performed as an endovascular procedure through a catheter, it is called ATHERECTOMY.

The use of systematic methods of ethical examination, such as CASUISTRY or ETHICAL THEORY, in reasoning about moral problems.

Surgical reconstruction of the breast including both augmentation and reduction.

Radiotherapy given to augment some other form of treatment such as surgery or chemotherapy. Adjuvant radiotherapy is commonly used in the therapy of cancer and can be administered before or after the primary treatment.

Quick Search

DeepDyve research library

Relevant Topics

Breast Cancer
Track and monitor developments in breast cancer research and commercial development.  Follow the tabs above to read the latest global news, research, clinical trials on breast cancer and follow companies active in the development of breast cancer tr...

Women's Health
Women's Health - key topics include breast cancer, pregnancy, menopause, stroke Follow and track Women's Health News on BioPortfolio: Women's Health News RSS Women'...

BioPortfolio - life science, medical devices and pharmaceutical conference
BioPortfolio is a leading news, information and knowledge resource covering the global life science industries impacted on by biotechnology. The site aims to provide the lay person, the researcher and the management executive with a single location to so...

Searches Linking to this Article