False prophets and Cassandra's curse: The role of credibility in belief updating.

07:00 EST 30th November 2019 | BioPortfolio

Summary of "False prophets and Cassandra's curse: The role of credibility in belief updating."

Information from other sources can be beneficial or detrimental, depending on the veracity of the report. Along with prior beliefs and context, recipients have two main routes to determine veracity; the perceived credibility of the source and direct-evaluation via first-hand evidence, i.e. testing the advice against observation. Using a probabilistic learning paradigm, we look at the interplay of these two factors in the uptake (or rejection) of communicated beliefs, and the subsequent evaluation of the credibility of the communicator in light of this process. Whether the communicated belief is false (Experiment 1), or true (Experiment 2), we show that beliefs are interpreted in light of the perceived credibility of the source, such that beliefs from high trust sources are taken up (hypothesis 1), whilst beliefs from low trust sources are treated with suspicion and potentially rejected - dependent on early evidence experiences (hypothesis 2). Finally, we show that these credibility-led biased interpretations of evidence (whether belief or suspicion confirming) lead to further polarization of the perceived credibility of communicators (hypothesis 3). Crucially, this occurs irrespective of the veracity of the communication, such that sources accompanied by a high trust cue not only get away with communicating falsehoods, but see their perceived credibility increase, whilst sources accompanied by low trust cues not only have truthful communications rejected, but have their low trust penalized even further. These findings carry important implications for the consequences of artificially inflating or deflating the credibility of communicators (e.g., politicians or scientists in public debate).


Journal Details

This article was published in the following journal.

Name: Acta psychologica
ISSN: 1873-6297
Pages: 102956


DeepDyve research library

PubMed Articles [9430 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Infants' performance in spontaneous-response false belief tasks: A review and meta-analysis.

Evidence obtained with new experimental paradigms has renewed the debate on the development of theory of mind in general and false belief ascription in particular. Namely, several studies contend to p...

Being Deceived: Information Asymmetry in Second-Order False Belief Tasks.

We analyze four well-known second-order false belief tasks. Superficially, all four tasks share a common logical structure: All are based around a principle of inertia, which says that an agent's beli...

Revisiting the relationship between the P3b and working memory updating.

The P3b is an extensively studied neurophysiological phenomenon that is predominantly explained in the cognitive neuroscience literature as reflecting context updating, presumably in working memory (W...

How do you know that? Automatic belief inferences in passing conversation.

There is an ongoing debate, both in philosophy and psychology, as to whether people are able to automatically infer what others may know, or whether they can only derive belief inferences by deploying...

Belief updating in depression is not related to increased sensitivity to unexpectedly negative information.

People with depression differ from healthy people in the extent to which they use novel positive information to adjust negative expectations. In this study, we examined whether the two groups also dif...

Clinical Trials [2554 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

Effects of Intranasal Oxytocin and Stress on Belief Updating

To investigate the effect of 24IU intranasal oxytocin on belief updating when people in stress or non-stress condition.

Cognitive Training in Parkinson's Disease, the iPARK Study

The aim of the iPARK-study is to investigate the effects of a process-based cognitive training program with focus on working memory in patients with Parkinson's Disease (PD). The study is ...

Attentional Control Training in Older Adults: Efficacy, Transfer and Brain Substrates

Formal education and cognitively stimulating hobbies and profession have a protective effect against age-related cognitive decline and Alzheimer's disease. It is therefore possible that pr...

Factors Associated With PSA False Negative and False Positive Results and the Impact on Patient's Health.

Objectives: The primary aim of this study is to evaluate the outcomes of the determination of PSA for the early detection of prostate cancer or in the presence of symptoms, in general pra...

Neural Account of Social Placebo Effect

The current study aimed to reveal the neural mechanism of social placebo belief formation and belief representation, and also investigated how the brain pattern predict the social behavior...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

A false belief regarding the self or persons or objects outside the self that persists despite the facts, and is not considered tenable by one's associates.

Not an aneurysm but a well-defined collection of blood and CONNECTIVE TISSUE outside the wall of a blood vessel or the heart. It is the containment of a ruptured blood vessel or heart, such as sealing a rupture of the left ventricle. False aneurysm is formed by organized THROMBUS and HEMATOMA in surrounding tissue.

Belief in a positive outcome.

A plant genus of the family LAMIACEAE that contains pulegone. Do not confuse with 'American false pennyroyal' (HEDEOMA).

Public false statements that are illegal and damaging to the reputation of a person, group, business, organization, or institution.

Quick Search

DeepDyve research library

Searches Linking to this Article