Evaluation of Open-canal Behind-the-Ear Hearing Aids and Traditional In-the-ear Hearing Aids.

2014-07-23 21:21:30 | BioPortfolio


This study is being conducted to evaluate the benefits of in-the-ear vs. open-fit behind-the-ear hearing aids. We want to learn more about which patients prefer each type, so we can make better choices about which type of hearing aid is best for which patients. Participants in this study will try three different sets of hearing aids for 2 months each, then we will evaluate the benefit of each type.


Hearing loss is the most common service-connected disability nationwide in the VHA system, with hearing aids providing the primary treatment option. Although the benefits of hearing-aid use are clearly established,~16-30% of adults who have hearing aids do not use them. Several factors are believed to result in non-use of traditional hearing aids, including (1) poor fit and comfort, (2) poor cosmetics, (3) whistling feedback, (4) occlusion, and (5) difficulty understanding speech in noise.

Recently, the open canal (OC) hearing-aid style has become a viable approach to addressing address many of the problems resulting in non-use of traditional hearing aids, particularly for individuals with mild to moderately-severe hearing loss. Although an OC hearing aid has many potential advantages, there also are potential limitations. For example, the maximum low and high-frequency gain available with an OC fitting is less than that available from traditional custom (TC) hearing-aid fittings, which could result in less than optimal amplification for some individuals. In addition, directional microphone benefits for speech understanding in noise, available with TC fittings, likely will be limited with OC fittings due to the loss of low-frequency gain (Ricketts et al., 2005).

Since both OC and TC fittings are appropriate for listeners with mild to moderately-severe hearing losses, evidence is needed to determine which style of hearing aid is preferred by a majority. Currently, OC fittings use a small behind-the-ear (BTE) hearing aid coupled to a thin tube or plastic covered wire ending in a vented "open" eartip. When a TC fitting is used with patients with similar hearing losses, the majority are either an in-the-ear (ITE) or in-the-canal (ITC) .In the proposed study a comparison will be made between OC vs. TC fittings.. In addition to this primary comparison, preference for one of two OC hearing aids, viz., OC instruments with receiver in the ear (OCRITE) and the OC instruments with receiver in the hearing-aid case (OCRIHA), will be determined. The outcomes of the OCRITE, OCRIHA, and TC hearing-aid use related to the factors of: (1) comfort and cosmetics, (2) subjective occlusion, (3) objective occlusion, (4) sound quality for external sounds, (5) feedback, (6) ease of use, (7) audibility, (8) aided signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) benefit, and (9) localization, will be measured in a large (n = 288), randomized-controlled, three-site (Bay Pines, Mountain Home, and Nashville) clinical trial, utilizing a three-period (two months each), cross-over design. A total of 13 variables will be measured for the 9 hearing-aid fitting and style-related factors. At the end of the study, participants will rank order their preferences for the three hearing aid fittings to determine (1) the preferred OC fitting (OCRITE vs. OCRIHA) and (2) whether the highest ranked OC fitting or the TC fitting is preferred. Preferred OC vs. TC difference scores will be calculated for all relevant variables. The ability of the differences scores to predict the preferences of the participants for an OC vs. TC hearing aid will be determined, in order to develop an evidence-based hearing aid selection model.

Study Design

Allocation: Non-Randomized, Control: Uncontrolled, Endpoint Classification: Efficacy Study, Intervention Model: Crossover Assignment, Masking: Open Label, Primary Purpose: Treatment


Hearing Loss


In-the-ear hearing aids, Behind-the-ear hearing aids, receiver-in-the canal, Behind-the-ear hearing aids, receiver-in-the-hearing aid


VA Medical Center, Bay Pines
Bay Pines
United States




Department of Veterans Affairs

Results (where available)

View Results


Published on BioPortfolio: 2014-07-23T21:21:30-0400

Clinical Trials [1646 Associated Clinical Trials listed on BioPortfolio]

Feasibility and Acceptability of Using Low-Gain Hearing Aids for Bothersome Tinnitus

Tinnitus - defined as ringing, humming, or other sounds in the ears or head - is a very common problem for Veterans. Hearing aids that deliver low-level amplification are being used by aud...

Clinical Trial on Alzheimer Disease, Presbycusis and Hearing Aids

This is a 12-months’ randomized clinical trial that aims at studying the benefit of bilateral hearing aids in hearing impaired patients suffering from a slight to moderate stage Alzheime...

Hearing Aids and the Brain

Hearing aids are used to improve audibility for patients with hearing loss and improve speech perception. In addition to these immediate benefits, amplification has the potential to have l...

Use of Hearing Aids. Development and Implementation of a Counselling Program for Hearing Aid Users

The proportion of elderly people is expected to increase greatly within the next couple of decades, resulting in a proportional increase in the need for hearing rehabilitation. However, st...

Evaluation of Middle Ear Implantation

The middle ear implant are used for patients with mild to severe sensorineural hearing loss, who cannot benefit from conventional hearing aids because of medical reasons such as chronic ex...

PubMed Articles [2178 Associated PubMed Articles listed on BioPortfolio]

Access To Hearing Care Services Among Older Medicare Beneficiaries Using Hearing Aids.

The Over-the-Counter Hearing Aid Act of 2017 will soon allow people to purchase hearing aids without an audiologist or hearing aid dispenser acting as a go-between. Under this new arrangement there wi...

Understanding Variability in Individual Response to Hearing Aid Signal Processing in Wearable Hearing Aids.

Previous work has suggested that individual characteristics, including amount of hearing loss, age, and working memory ability, may affect response to hearing aid signal processing. The present study ...

Cost-Benefit Analysis of Hearing Care Services: What Is It Worth to Medicare?

Hearing care services for older adults with hearing aids are underutilized and are not covered by the Medicare program. Little information exists to the value of hearing care services for older adults...

Hearing aid provision - can the limited obligation of statutory health insurance to provide indemnification only up to the reference price be successfully challenged in the social courts in cases of medical indication?

When patients are provided with hearing aids, the question may arise whether they are entitled to technically advanced and therefore more expensive hearing aids in cases of medical indication, or just...

Receptive and productive speech and language abilities in hearing-impaired children with German as a second language.

Many studies examining early bilingualism in migrant populations focus on the development of the first language. As language acquisition is closely related to the hearing development, there is a criti...

Medical and Biotech [MESH] Definitions

Wearable sound-amplifying devices that are intended to compensate for impaired hearing. These generic devices include air-conduction hearing aids and bone-conduction hearing aids. (UMDNS, 1999)

A prodromal phase of infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Laboratory criteria separating AIDS-related complex (ARC) from AIDS include elevated or hyperactive B-cell humoral immune responses, compared to depressed or normal antibody reactivity in AIDS; follicular or mixed hyperplasia in ARC lymph nodes, leading to lymphocyte degeneration and depletion more typical of AIDS; evolving succession of histopathological lesions such as localization of Kaposi's sarcoma, signaling the transition to the full-blown AIDS.

Transmission of sound waves through vibration of bones in the SKULL to the inner ear (COCHLEA). By using bone conduction stimulation and by bypassing any OUTER EAR or MIDDLE EAR abnormalities, hearing thresholds of the cochlea can be determined. Bone conduction hearing differs from normal hearing which is based on air conduction stimulation via the EAR CANAL and the TYMPANIC MEMBRANE.

Hearing loss due to interference with the mechanical reception or amplification of sound to the COCHLEA. The interference is in the outer or middle ear involving the EAR CANAL; TYMPANIC MEMBRANE; or EAR OSSICLES.

Professionals skilled at diagnostic testing of hearing, HEARING IMPAIRMENT, and CORRECTION OF HEARING IMPAIRMENT by non-medical or non-surgical means.

More From BioPortfolio on "Evaluation of Open-canal Behind-the-Ear Hearing Aids and Traditional In-the-ear Hearing Aids."

Quick Search

Relevant Topics

Hearing, auditory perception, or audition is the ability to perceive sound by detecting vibrations, changes in the pressure of the surrounding medium through time, through an organ such as the ear. Sound may be heard through solid, liquid, or gaseous mat...

Clincial Trials
In a clinical trial or interventional study, participants receive specific interventions according to the research plan or protocol created by the investigators. These interventions may be medical products, such as drugs or devices; procedures; or change...

Searches Linking to this Trial